# What football clubs could do with AI if it started with the fans they already know

How AI could help a football club recognise its supporters and act on what they say: a demo on sample data, and what Liverpool FC’s public documents show.

- Author: Dan Mocan (https://www.linkedin.com/in/dan-mocan-9424421a/)
- Published: 2026-11-09
- Kind: Building
- Demo: https://football-supporter-view.x2labs.ai/?embed=1 (Live demo · a fictional club with sample data, not a real club’s records)
- Page: https://x2labs.ai/notes/football-supporter-view

**TL;DR**

- Who we are: X2 Labs helps football clubs adopt AI, one problem at a time. This is the third tool we’ve built for clubs.
- The question: can a club recognise the needs of its own supporters, and get what they say to someone who can act on it?
- What I built: a demo of a supporter tool for a club. It has a call screen, complaints on a stadium map, a watch list of fans who may be drifting away, and a pilot tracker.
- What I found: Liverpool FC’s public documents show listening at scale (over 62,000 survey responses), but nothing showing what one supporter said reaching the next person they talk to.
- My take: start with supporter services, not marketing. One season, one stadium, with the supporters’ trust and telling what is being tested.

A supporter calls the ticket office to ask why their season ticket renewal failed.

The club knows a lot about this person. They have held a season ticket for eleven years. They bought a shirt for their daughter last Christmas. They complained twice this season about the queue at the same gate. They use the app on matchdays but stopped opening the club’s emails in the spring.

The person answering the phone sees almost none of it. They see a payment that did not go through.

Most clubs collect plenty of information about their supporters. Ticketing, membership, retail, the app, hospitality, the foundation and customer service each hold a piece. In my experience, the pieces rarely meet in one place, and they almost never reach the person having the conversation.

## Why it is getting harder

A big club now has two very different audiences. One is a local, match-going base that has been coming for decades. The other is a global audience that may never visit the stadium but follows the club through apps, streaming and social media. Both expect to be recognised. They do not want the same things.

The match-going base is also under strain. Nineteen of the twenty Premier League clubs raised ticket prices for 2024-25, and 13 did so again the following season (DAZN, November 2025). In November 2025, 116 supporter organisations co-signed a Football Supporters’ Association letter asking clubs to freeze home prices for two seasons and share their pricing data. The Chelsea Supporters’ Trust was among them.

That matters for anyone building AI for fan engagement. The obvious use is to sell more: better targeting, dynamic pricing, offers timed to the moment a fan is most likely to buy. Some of that is legitimate. But supporters are already sensitive to being treated as a revenue line, and a system that squeezes them more efficiently will be noticed.

The more useful question is different. Can the club recognise the people that love it, and treat them accordingly?

## What a missed signal costs

Go back to the season ticket holder. Over the season, there were signs. They stopped opening emails. They complained twice about the same gate. They listed their seat on the resale platform for four matches, which they had never done before.

Each department saw one of those signals. Nobody saw all three together.

In the spring, the renewal fails. The ticket office treats it as a payment problem. The supporter, who was already wondering whether the cost was worth it, takes the failed payment as a sign and does not renew.

For a club with a waiting list, the seat will be resold. On a spreadsheet, nothing is lost. But the club has lost an eleven-year relationship, a family that bought merchandise, and someone who would have told friends the club treated them well. It may also have gained a supporter who tells friends the opposite.

The reverse also happens. A loyal fan receives a generic offer to buy hospitality the week after writing to complain. The message is not wrong. It is just badly timed, and it tells the fan that nobody read the complaint.

## What Liverpool’s public documents show

To check whether this gap is real, I looked at Liverpool FC. I picked Liverpool because, in my experience, it publishes more about its supporters than most clubs. I used only documents anyone can open: the club’s ticketing survey report (April 2025), its Supporter Charter 2025/26, its contact pages and job adverts, and legal commentary on the new football regulator. Nobody at the club was interviewed, so anything here about how the club works internally is an inference from what it publishes.

The listening is real, and large. In October 2024 the club invited over 500,000 ticket users to a survey and received over 62,000 responses, broken down by segment. Season ticket holders living in Liverpool named ticket pricing as their top topic; those living elsewhere named away and final tickets. Across all supporters, touting and away tickets scored 1.8 out of 5, the lowest of 15 topics. The club’s charter promises to acknowledge a complaint within 2 hours and give an initial response within 14 days, with a named person managing it.

That machinery works in aggregate. What I could not find is how that reaches the next conversation with the same supporter.

**Where Liverpool’s supporter feedback goes**

From the club’s public documents, read in November 2026. “Not shown” means not in any public document, not that it doesn’t happen.

| Channel                         | Where it publicly goes               | Reaches the next conversation? |
| ------------------------------- | ------------------------------------ | ------------------------------ |
| Ticketing survey                | Ticketing review, published report   | Not shown                      |
| Complaints                      | Named handler, escalation, Ombudsman | Only the open case             |
| Post-contact survey             | Not published                        | Not shown                      |
| Matchday WhatsApp reports       | Stewarding response                  | Not shown                      |
| Supporters Board and Fan Forums | Meeting summaries, annual report     | No, by design                  |

Three gaps follow:

- **Aggregate versus individual.** Season ticket holders scored access to away tickets 1.9 out of 5 in the survey. The survey cannot tell an agent that the person on the phone gave that score, complained twice, and has started listing seats on the ticket exchange. The club may join these internally; it publishes nothing showing it does.
- **Response time versus the moment.** A 14-day initial response is reasonable for most complaints. It is long when the complaint is open during a renewal window and the supporter is deciding whether to continue.
- **Evidence for the regulator.** From the 2027/28 season, clubs in the top five men’s divisions need a licence from the Independent Football Regulator, and fan consultation is one of its conditions. The application window opened on 2 November 2026, and each club must send an annual Fan Consultation Report by 15 August. That needs a trail from what fans raised to what changed, and no public Liverpool document links complaint themes to fixes over a season. Keeping that trail is one of the things this tool is designed to do.

A one-view tool fits the service gaps. It does not touch the issues supporters rank highest: the scarcity of away and final tickets, ticket pricing, or touting itself. And the gap may be smaller inside the club than it looks from outside.

## What we are building

We are building a system that brings a club’s supporter information into one view: ticketing and membership history, app use, retail purchases, service requests and complaints. The first job is simply recognition. When a supporter contacts the club, the person responding can see who they are and what has happened recently.

The second part is reading what fans tell the club. Complaints, emails, app messages and survey comments are read and grouped by topic and location. A single complaint about a gate is an incident. Two hundred complaints about the same gate across a season is a pattern, and it should reach whoever can fix the gate as well as the person who answers the email.

A head of supporter services can ask in plain language:

“Which long-standing season ticket holders have contacted us more than once this season without a resolved case, and what were they about?”

The answer comes from the club’s own records, with links back to each original message.

The third part is early warning. Changes in behaviour, such as fewer matches attended, more resale listings or less engagement with the app, can suggest that someone is drifting away. The system flags those cases for a person to look at. What happens next, whether that is a call, a resolved complaint or nothing at all, is decided by staff.

Every part of this is designed to run on AI. It matches the same fan across ticketing, retail and the app, reads complaints and groups them by topic and place, answers staff questions in plain language, and spots changes in behaviour. People make every decision; the AI does the reading and connecting no one has time for.

We have also set a boundary deliberately. The tool is designed to help the club look after supporters, not to work out how much more each one will pay.

The demo above shows all of this for a fictional club, Eastmoor FC, with about 3,000 generated supporters and 804 generated messages. Things to try:

- **Calls:** a supporter rings about a failed renewal. Tick the actions: fix the payment, link his open Gate 7 complaint, hold the hospitality email. Then decide whether a possible duplicate record is the same person.
- **Complaints:** tap Gate 7 on the stadium map, then ask both questions under it. The second one, about which loyal fans would tolerate a price rise, is declined.
- **Watch list:** open a fan to see the evidence behind each warning sign, and mark them “Worth a call” or “Leave it”. Switch to 2+ signs to see the list grow from 8 to 52.
- **Pilot tracker:** everything you did shows up here, against the measures a pilot would be judged on.

In the demo, the messages are generated and already grouped; no model reads them yet. The questions are fixed, and nothing you click is sent anywhere.

## What still needs people

Supporters are not customers in the usual sense. Many of them will never switch clubs, which is exactly why they notice when they are taken for granted. Knowing how to respond to a long-standing fan who feels let down is a human skill. A system can bring the history to the conversation. It should not write the apology.

The club also has to decide what kind of relationship it wants. Ticket pricing, loyalty schemes and how to balance local and global fans are strategic choices for the board, ideally made after listening to supporter groups. A tool can show the club what its fans are saying. It cannot decide what to do about it.

## What it will not solve

It cannot fix a pricing policy that supporters think is unfair. If the underlying complaint is cost, faster and friendlier responses will help at the margin, but they will not make the issue go away.

It depends on the club actually acting on what it learns. A system that identifies the same gate complaint every week is useless if nobody fixes the gate.

Privacy is the other limit. Bringing supporter data together is only acceptable if fans know what is collected, why, and how it is used. Data protection law sets a floor, not a ceiling. The club should be able to explain the system to a supporters’ trust without embarrassment, and decide who inside the club can see what.

And there is the usual risk that a tidy profile looks more complete than it is. A fan who stopped opening emails may just have changed address. People need to see the evidence behind any flag and be free to ignore it.

## Where it stands

- **The problem** (19 Oct, done): What the tool is for, and what it should not do, written down.
- **Demo** (9 Nov, done): Calls, complaints map, watch list and pilot tracker, on a fictional club with sample data.
- **Liverpool desk study** (9 Nov, done): What one club’s public documents show about its supporter feedback, and what they don’t.
- **A club’s own records** (Next, next): Run it on one club’s ticketing and service-desk exports, starting with record matching.

## What we are still testing

We have not yet tested whether the system matches records correctly. The same fan can appear as several people across ticketing, retail and the app. Merging them wrongly is worse than not merging them at all.

We have not yet tested whether the early warnings are worth the attention they demand. If staff receive fifty flags a week and most lead nowhere, they will stop looking.

And we want to understand how supporters feel about it. A tool that makes service better but feels intrusive will not last.

We do not yet have evidence that this improves retention or satisfaction. The narrower question is whether the people who talk to supporters every day have a clearer picture of who they are talking to.

If you work on supporter services, membership or fan engagement at a club, I would like to hear what you think the right boundaries are.

## My take

I am wary of most AI fan engagement pitches. Many of them are really about extracting more revenue from people who are already paying a lot and are increasingly vocal about it.

I think the better use is more modest. Help the club remember what it already knows about its supporters, notice when something is going wrong, and get the problem to someone who can fix it. Loyal fans mostly want to be recognised and listened to.

I would start with supporter services rather than marketing. One season, one stadium, with the supporters’ trust told what is being tested and invited to challenge it.

**Sources**

- Premier League clubs urged to freeze home ticket prices, DAZN, November 2025
- Liverpool FC Supporter Ticketing Survey Research Report, April 2025
- Liverpool FC Supporter Charter 2025/26
- Liverpool FC Supporter Services contact page and help centre
- Liverpool FC casual Supporter Services Specialists job advert
- The IFR licensing regime, Lewis Silkin, September 2026

**If you want to read more**

- [When a fixture moves, what breaks? A football travel dashboard](https://x2labs.ai/notes/football-team-travel-planner) · Dan Mocan · 2 Nov 2026
- [Cash forecasts for football clubs: 18% of contract terms fixed by hand](https://x2labs.ai/notes/football-club-cash-forecast) · Dan Mocan · 19 Oct 2026
